The juror who, a couple of weeks ago, forced the nullification of the trial of Lindsay Clancy, a nurse who strangled her three children and then tried to commit suicide, is named Michael Péguy Desronvil. This Friday he published, through a lawyer expert in defamation, a statement reaffirming the conviction he defended in front of his 11 peers during an extraordinarily high-profile process: that Clancy is guilty, that “she knew exactly what she was doing and had it all planned.”
Read more The Generalitat announces an extra 30 million to combat homelessness in Catalonia
Desronvil, 48 years old, maintained his position during the 38 hours of deliberation based, the statement says, “on all the material evidence, on the key witnesses and on what the Prosecutor’s Office presented.” And so, the jury did not achieve the unanimity required by law to convict Clancy, who was being prosecuted for something she herself admitted: having killed her three children, during, according to the defense, an episode of “postpartum psychosis.”
The other 11 members were inclined to acquit her of the charges of murder and involuntary manslaughter. During the debate, Desronvil says in his statement that his colleagues repeatedly interrupted him whenever he tried to present his theories about the case.
In view of the deadlock, the judge declared the trial null and void, held in Plymouth (Massachusetts), broadcast live, with global impact, by US television and dissected on social media. A hearing is scheduled that will be crucial to decide whether the Prosecutor’s Office will refile charges or if, as allowed by the law of the state in the East of the country, it will reach an agreement with the defense.
Clancy faced five possible verdicts: three of guilt (first-degree murder, second-degree murder, or manslaughter) and two of innocence (generally or due to lack of criminal responsibility). The dilemma is, therefore, the following: either she was responsible for her actions and must then spend the rest of her days in prison or the alleged mental illness exonerates her, in which case she must be admitted to a psychiatric hospital similar to the one where she is now. The only clear thing at this point is that, whatever the outcome, Clancy will not be released for many months, perhaps years.
Read more Operation High Eagle: Mexico and United States efforts at the border take down four drones
The accused has admitted at all times that on January 24, 2023, she killed Cora, five years old, Dawson, three, and Callan, eight months old. She had sent her husband, Patrick Clancy, who testified at the trial, on an errand. Lindsay did so after hearing, she declared, the voice of a man who urged her to strangle her children and then commit suicide. She ingested sleeping pills, cut her veins, and threw herself from a second floor. She did not die but was left confined to a wheelchair. In the previous months, she had been examined by several psychiatrists, called the suicide prevention hotline, and went to the emergency room.
Desronvil, whose identity was secret but was revealed this week by The Boston Globe, whose reporters cross-checked data and images taken from social media, considers that Clancy did all the above with premeditation.
The defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, with a long history of successful strategies focused on women’s mental health, confronted Desronvil with the judge at the end of the process. It was when he unsuccessfully tried to convince him to dismiss the dissenting juror, considering that he was “refusing to understand” the concept of “reasonable doubt” that the magistrate repeated twice they should take into account in their verdict.
Read more A 13-year-old student stabs his teacher in Rome and records the attack
[Breaking news. There will be an update shortly].
